Dilemma Over Ink Bottles

My assignment was to create a photograph that showed examples of analogous colors. According to my professor, my photograph was a dynamite image that was technically well done. Unfortunately he gave me a lower grade because the colors where not exactly analogous. I went back later and in post altered the color to satisfy my professor. I'm debating if I like the changes or not.

Original Version


Version 2

Version 3Let me know what you think?